Judgment 5136/19

Applicant name LEBED AND OTHERS
Applicant type natural person (prisoner)
Number of applicants 47
Country Russia
Application no.5136/19 5210/19 5345/19 5354/19 5355/19 6443/19 7231/19 7232/19 8388/19 10048/19 10839/19 10855/19 10902/19 11420/19 12437/19 13039/19 13043/19 13548/19 13931/19 14059/19 14276/19 14393/19 14689/19 14709/19 14848/19 15002/19 16135/19 16426/19 17445/19 18684/19 19275/19 19487/19 21292/19 21845/19 22505/19 22974/19 23509/19 23786/19 24307/19 24357/19 24359/19 24488/19 24544/19 24820/19 25358/19 26135/19 26257/19
Date 11/01/2024
Judges Branko Lubarda, President,
 Armen Harutyunyan,
 Ana Maria Guerra Martins
Institution Court
Type Judgment
Outcome Art. 8 Violation
Reason unlawfull
Type of privacy Relational privacy
Keywords Family visit
Facts of the case Art. 8 (1) – restrictions on family visits in pre-trial facilities – lack of and restrictions on visits by applicant’s family during her pre-trial detention from 02/07/2014 to 04/09/2018 in SIZO-3, Samara; SIZO-2 Syzran; SIZO-4 Tolyatti; IVS in Samara; refusal of short-term family visits, refusal of long-term family visits, limitation on the frequency of short-term family visits
Analysis mini-judgment
Other Article violation? Yes, many
Damage awarded 8.500 for the 1 applicant that invoked 8 ECHR
Documents Judgment