Judgment 38521/16

Applicant name KLYACHKOV AND OTHERS
Applicant type Natural person (prisoner)
Number of applicants 42
Country Russia
Application no.38521/16, 20728/17, 47409/17, 70513/17
74882/17, 36597/18, 38005/18, 38870/18
38872/18, 39937/18, 39953/18, 40611/18
41569/18, 41691/18, 41766/18, 42017/18
45962/18, 47301/18, 48919/18, 48934/18
50630/18, 50639/18, 51223/18, 51644/18
55027/18, 55422/18, 55598/18, 55653/18
55690/18, 55731/18, 55741/18, 55758/18
55760/18, 56256/18, 57269/18, 57308/18
57820/18, 57831/18, 58064/18, 58274/18
58528/18, 58551/18
Date 02/11/2023
Judges Lorraine Schembri Orland, President,
 Frédéric Krenc,
 Davor Derenčinović
Institution Court
Type Judgment
Outcome Art. 8 Violation
Reason No legal basis
Type of privacy Realtional privacy
Keywords Family visit
Facts of the case Main judgement about Article 3 ECHR, one applicant also invokes Art. 8 (1) – restrictions on family visits in pre-trial facilities – limitation on visits in remand prison: the applicant complained that, within the period of his detention in the SIZO-1 of Moscow and SIZO-1 St Petersburg (03/04/2015 – 03/04/2016) he was allowed visits with his wife only twice
Analysis Mini judgement
Other Article violation? yes many,
Damage awarded The applicant invoking Article 8 ECHR is awarded 9750
Documents Judgment